November 15, 2009Trends Audio PA-10 SE
Preamplifier and TA-10.2P SE Power Amplifier
Trends Audio, based in
Hong Kong, has been around only a few years, but have made a name for themselves with a
series of inexpensive but high-quality, ultracompact audio components. I reviewed their
Tripath-based TA-10.1 integrated switching
amplifier and UD-10.1 USB digital converter,
and was thoroughly impressed by both. In fact, I use the UD-10.1 in my reference system to
convert the USB output of my laptop computer to S/PDIF, to send digital audio signals to
an Anthem D2 audio/video processor. This combination of elements has become my main audio
source.
The latest products from Trends are the PA-10 tube
headphone preamplifier and TA-10.2P power amplifier. I was sent the upgraded, Special
Edition versions: the PA-10 SE ($265 USD) and TA-10.2P SE ($199). The standard PA-10 and
TA-10.2P cost $225 and $179, respectively. (Trends also offers the PA-10 GE version of the
preamp, also priced at $265 and identical to the PA-10 SE, except for the fact that it
comes with a US-made GE 12AU7 tube instead of a Russian 6H23n tube.)
Description
Like other Trends products, the two SE models are housed in
small aluminum enclosures; each measures 2.96"W x 1.8"H x 4.4"D, not
including knobs or plugs. The finish is a big improvement over the earlier models
dowdy matte gray: the newbies are coated in attractive black enamel, with silver front and
rear plates.
The PA-10 SE uses a single Russian 6H23n tube (the standard
PA-10 has a Chinese 6N11 tube) and upgraded EVOX capacitors. On the rear panel are two
pairs of RCA inputs with a sliding switch to select between them, one pair of RCA outputs,
the power toggle switch, and the DC power input for the external power supply (a wall
wart). The front panel has only a volume control and a 1/8" headphone jack. The
lightweight plastic volume knob has a less positive feel than I would have liked, but on
such an inexpensive product its excusable. Power-on status is indicated by the glow
of the tube itself, whose top pokes up above the case, as well as a blue LED mounted
inside, below the tube.
The TA-10.2P SE is the power-amplifier version of
Trends TA-10.1 switch-mode integrated amplifier, with a few modifications. It uses
the same Tripath TA2024 chip, but has Trends new MKP audio input decoupling
capacitors and Rubycon MCZ power-filtering caps. The TA-10.2P SE is further differentiated
from the standard version by an upgraded power supply rated at 48W and 4 amps (vs. 36W and
3 amps). Trends claims that the SEs power output is up to 10Wpc into 8 ohms or 15Wpc
into 4 ohms. On the rear panel, between the pairs of relatively high-quality speaker
binding posts, is a pair of RCA inputs. Still, the binding posts are fairly close
together; I recommend high-quality banana plugs or bare wire. On the right are a power
toggle switch and a DC power inlet for the external power supply. On the front panel is
nothing but a blue power-indicator LED.
Setup
I used the PA-10 SE and TA-10.2P SE with pairs of Paradigm
Cinema 330 and Athena AS-B1 loudspeakers and an Oppo Digital DV-970HD SACD/CD/DVD player.
(This system is usually amplified by the aforementioned Trends TA-10.1 integrated.) Audio
Magic Xstream speaker cables and interconnects were used, as was a pair of Sennheiser HD
580 headphones.
Prior to beginning listening, or after changing tubes,
Trends strongly recommends that the user adjust the DC bias voltage of each channel of the
PA-10 SE, and periodically thereafter -- it can drift. I did this fairly easily with a
digital multimeter, and soon was ready to begin listening. I found that the PA-10 SE
sounded best after warming up for a few minutes; its aluminum case grew relatively hot
during normal use.
Listening
I was impressed by the richness of sound produced by the
Trends Audio SE duo, especially compared with the sound of my TA-10.1 integrated. There
was now more bottom end, and although the TA-10.2P SE power amp has the same power rating
as the TA-10.1, the sound was subjectively louder.
The Paradigm Cinema 330 is a slim, midsized speaker
primarily designed to be mounted on walls. It has five drivers, but its bass and midrange
cones are only 4.5" in diameter, and its cabinet is sealed. Even so, the sound was
full-bodied with the Trends combo -- satisfyingly so for a relatively small speaker --
with good depth and an immediacy to voices. Peter Gabriels voice on the title track
of his Shaking the Tree (SACD/CD, Geffen 606949362829) was sparklingly clear, and
Youssou NDours backing vocal was solid and soulful. Although the bass was a
little lightweight, probably primarily due to the Cinema 330s limited low-end
extension, it was tight and well defined. The piano and guitars exhibited good dynamic
range that provided a sound that was surprisingly big and powerful. And the bass was
exceptionally taut on "Biko," with excellent imaging on a hauntingly wide
soundstage.
Neko Cases slightly diffuse, ethereal voice, on her Fox
Confessor Brings the Flood (CD, Anti- 04577867772), was especially alluring, floating
between the speakers in "Margaret vs. Pauline." In "The Needle Touched
Down," her voice was a bit more precise than on most of the other tracks, as were the
guitar, various strings, and snare drum. While the PA-10 SE and TA-10.2P SE didnt
exert the kind of vise-like grip and pinpoint imaging that Im accustomed to hearing
from larger, more expensive amplifiers, the sound was exceptionally pleasing for such
inexpensive gear.
After switching to the Athena AS-B1 bookshelf speakers, I
definitely heard more bass -- perhaps a bit too much. Actually, it was less that
there was too much bass than that what bass there was was a little vague and undefined.
The drumbeats that open "Biko" were deep and ominous but slightly overblown. The
purer midrange of the Paradigm Cinemas also served the Trends combo well, with wonderful
vocals that the Athenas couldnt match. Overall, the PA-10 SE and TA-10.2P SE still
sounded very good through the Athenas, but I preferred them with the more balanced and
neutral-sounding Paradigm Cinema 330s, even though there was less bass.
I heard the same bold, luxurious sound when listening to
the Sennheiser HD 580s plugged into the PA-10 SEs headphone jack. Sarah
McLachlans voice on Surfacing (CD, Nettwerk 067003011624) was breathy and
silky-smooth. The exceptional reproduction of instruments on her "Sweet
Surrender," along with excellent dynamics and plenty of drive, let me easily follow
the flow of the music. More rocking albums also sounded fantastic -- such as Please
Please Me, from The Beatles in Mono (CD, Capitol 5099969945120). There was a
clean, punchy sound to "I Saw Her Standing There" that precisely delineated the
vocals from the guitars, bass, percussion, and handclaps. George Harrisons bluesy
guitar solo sounded especially energetic through the PA-10 SE and the Sennheisers.
Comparison
The PA-10 SE and TA-10.2P SE pre/power amplifier combo was
clearly superior to Trends TA-10.1 integrated amplifier ($179) -- only to be
expected, considering the $285 difference in price. While the TA-10.1 sounded excellent
for such an inexpensive, ultracompact integrated, the SE duo simply sounded more
substantial and better fleshed out.
With the Trends SEs, the Paradigm Cinema 330 speakers
played louder and were more extended in the bass, and thus sounded more like large
bookshelf speakers and less like slim "lifestyle" models. The midrange was
smoother and seemed better integrated with the highs and lows, resulting in a deeper, more
continuous soundstage in which instruments and voices blended seamlessly. Neko Cases
voice was even more lucid and expressive in her "The Needle Touched Down," and
the soundstage was surprisingly wide.
But while the SE pairing had a bolder sound, they
didnt necessarily sound any less neutral than the TA-10.1 -- or any more
neutral, as might be expected of two components that, together, represent a 259% increase
in retail price. What the SEs did do was play louder with less noticeable distortion and a
fuller sound, making the TA-10.1 sound a bit thin in comparison.
But it wasnt only the tubed PA-10 SE preamplifier
that contributed to the superior sound of the SE combo over the TA-10.1 integrated. When
compared to the TA-10.1, its internal jumpers configuring to operate as only a power amp,
the TA-10.2P SE exhibited better control over the bass and a more balanced sound overall.
At times, the TA-10.1 sounded somewhat lean in comparison.
Used by itself as a headphone amp, the PA-10 SE had a
richer sound than HeadRooms Total BitHead ($159). The BitHead has a pretty good
built-in DAC, is able to draw power from the USB output, and includes HeadRooms
patented Crossfeed circuit for more natural imaging, but it didnt sound as powerful
as the PA-10 SE. Although the PA-10 SE imaged more "inside" the head, as do most
headphone amps, everything sounded bigger and less constrained. The lower registers of the
piano in "Oh Mary," from Neil Diamonds 12 Songs (CD, Columbia
82796947782), were powerfully stirring, and Diamonds smoky voice had more body and
palpability. And the PA-10 SE was better able to drive the Sennheisers to higher levels
without distortion.
Although I loved the rich, hybrid sound of the PA-10 SE in
combination with the TA-10.2P SE, the latters low power output will require some
care in matching speakers. The SE duo drove both the Paradigm Cinema 330 and Athena AS-B1
speakers to moderate listening levels, but werent able to push them to
party-approved levels. Companies such as NAD and Cambridge Audio make higher-powered,
solid-state integrated amps in this price range that offer the flexibility of more inputs
and remote-control operation. If you dont need this kind of additional power, and
can get by with only two inputs and without a remote control, the Trends SEs should give
you the sort of thoroughly involving sound thats seldom heard from such affordable
products.
Conclusion
I absolutely enjoyed my time with the tiny Trends Audio
PA-10 SE preamplifier and TA-10.2P SE power amplifier. The SEs cost significantly more
than the earlier Trends products Ive heard and admired, and with higher costs come
higher expectations of sound quality -- in that regard, these models delivered. Like their
predecessors, the new Trends components gave me hours of musical enjoyment and made
reviewing them a pleasure.
I dont think the SEs are quite as incredible a value
as the TA-10.1 integrated amplifier, which once retailed for only $129, let alone the
original TA-10, which cost a mere $99 -- very few products could. That said, the PA-10 SE
and TA-10.2P SE comprise a good-sounding, compact tube-and-solid-state amplification
system for $464 -- a price I consider to be still very reasonable.
. . . Roger Kanno
Trends Audio PA-10 SE Preamplifier
Price: $265 USD.
Trends Audio TA-10.2P SE Power Amplifier
Price: $199 USD.
Warranty (both): One year parts and labor.
Trends Audio
ITOK Media Limited
Unit E, 13/F, World Tech Centre
95 How Ming Street
Kwun Tong, Hong Kong
Phone: +852 2304 0730
Fax: +852 2566 5740
E-mail: support@trendsaudio.com
Website: www.trendsaudio.com
|