April 1, 2009 Featured
Release: U2, No Line on the Horizon
Interscope/Island/Universal B0012630-02
Format: CD
Musical Performance |
     |
Sound Quality |
     |
Overall Enjoyment |
     |
U2 has reached a point where the group’s
dominance on the world stage makes it difficult to approach them as a mere rock band. The
CD booklet that accompanies their latest album, No Line on the Horizon, includes
information about several NGOs and encourages us to support them, as if to remind us of
singer Bono’s stature as conscience, global leader, and world citizen. Two more pages
thank a dizzying number of people, one or two of whom might even have something to do with
music.
So, is it good? Well, yes -- very good. If, like me, you
thought everything from Achtung Baby through How to Dismantle an Atom Bomb a
bit overrated or overblown, you can come home. No Line on the Horizon is the most
consistent, impassioned, and heartfelt U2 album since Achtung Baby, and the most
effortlessly compelling since The Joshua Tree.
Part of the reason No Line flows so easily is that
U2 have made peace with their past, a process they began with Atom Bomb. The
guitars in "Magnificent" recall those in October or War, while
"Unknown Caller" and "Moment of Surrender" contain some of the
atmospheric flow of Joshua Tree. Perhaps it’s not surprising that U2 would
return to that breakthrough disc, which, like so much of their work, and this new record
as well, was produced by Brian Eno and Daniel Lanois (with assistance from Steve
Lillywhite). No Line on the Horizon succeeds because U2 has returned to their
signature style without merely recycling it, and when they try new things, such as the
Springsteen-ish "I’ll Go Crazy If I Don’t Go Crazy Tonight," they
don’t sound as if they’re trying to squeeze into an ill-fitting suit.
Eno and Lanois, who are also listed as cowriters of a
number of tunes here, have given No Line on the Horizon an ambiance at times
strikingly similar to Coldplay’s Viva la Vida, to which Eno made
similar contributions. To me, Eno’s sonic enhancements to Viva la Vida only
underlined Coldplay’s calculated attempts to be relevant and innovative. On No
Line on the Horizon, U2 invests Eno’s potentially cold technology with passion,
and it makes all the difference. The songs touch on all of U2’s convictions, from
politics to spirituality, with love as the glue that holds them together. Bono sings
without reservation or hesitation, and with sincerity enough to inspire the
listener’s trust.
The album isn’t quite perfect. "Get On Your
Boots" is just not a good song, and some of the longer tracks, such as "Unknown
Caller" and "Moment of Surrender," could have been trimmed. The sound is
compressed and occasionally mushy. Eno’s aural effects add a good deal of variety and
come through clearly, but the kick drum is often mixed too high, while the rest of the kit
is pushed to the background. Adam Clayton’s bass is strongly present, but
there’s no attack -- it could just as well be a synth bass. Bono’s voice is
clear and centered on some tunes, but on others, such as the title track and
"Magnificent," it’s folded into the rest of the mix. But audiophiles
don’t listen to U2 for the quality of their recordings, any more than they do Bruce
Springsteen. U2’s music is about passion and memorable songs. On those terms, No
Line on the Horizon is a triumph and a surprise.
. . . Joseph Taylor
|